6 min read

Cloud vs on-premise: how to decide where your systems should live

The short version#

On-premise (often shortened to “on-prem”) means your software runs on hardware you own, in a building you control: a server in the office closet, or a rack in your own data room. Cloud means it runs on someone else’s hardware in their data centers, reached over the internet, and you pay as you go. On-premise gives you the most control and a cost you pay mostly up front. Cloud gives you speed and someone else to handle the hardware, at a cost you pay every month for as long as you use it. Most companies end up with a mix, and the right question is rarely “cloud or not?” but “which system goes where, and why?”

If you’re new to the cloud side of this, our explainer on cloud computing in simple terms sets out the basics first.

Side by side#

On-premiseCloud
Who owns the hardwareYouThe provider
How you payMostly up front (servers, licenses), plus upkeepSubscription or metered usage, monthly
Time to add capacityOrder, ship, install: days to weeksMinutes to hours
Who patches and replaces hardwareYou or your IT partnerThe provider
Who patches the softwareYouThe provider for SaaS; you for virtual servers you rent
Physical location of dataYour buildingProvider’s data centers, often in regions you choose
Works if the internet is downYes, inside the officeUsually not
Remote access for staffNeeds extra setupBuilt in
Exit costHardware keeps running; you own itNeed to export data and move
Best forSpecialized, latency-sensitive or offline-critical systemsMost business applications

The analogy: your own kitchen vs a rented commercial kitchen#

A restaurant can build its own kitchen. It buys the ovens, pays the electrician, and fixes the walk-in freezer when it breaks on a Saturday night. Nobody else touches the equipment, and once it’s paid off, the ongoing cost is mainly power and repairs. But if the restaurant doubles in size, it needs a bigger kitchen, and that’s a construction project.

Or it can rent space in a commercial kitchen. The landlord maintains the ovens and the freezer. You can rent more hours during the holidays and fewer in January. But the rent never stops, you follow the building’s rules, and you can’t rip out a wall to fit a special pizza oven.

Neither is wrong. A bakery with a 100-year-old wood-fired oven keeps its own kitchen. A new catering company rents.

How the money really compares#

On-premise looks cheaper once the hardware is paid for, and cloud looks cheaper in year one. Both views leave things out. A fair comparison counts the full cost over three to five years, often called total cost of ownership:

ON-PREMISE, 5 YEARS CLOUD, 5 YEARS
------------------- -------------------
Servers + storage (year 1) Monthly subscription
Software licenses (year 1) or usage, x 60
Backup hardware (year 1) Data transfer fees
Power + cooling (every year) Support plan
IT time / partner (every year) IT time / partner
Replacement parts (as needed) (usually less)
Hardware refresh (year 4-6) Price changes at renewal
Software end of life (as needed)

The line people forget on the on-premise side is end of life. Software stops getting security fixes on a set date, and running it past that point is a risk. For example, Microsoft’s lifecycle page for Windows Server 2016 lists its extended support end date as 2027-01-13. A company still running that version faces an upgrade, a hardware refresh or a move, whatever it decides about the cloud.

The line people forget on the cloud side is that the bill doesn’t end, and usage-based services grow quietly. Budget alerts and quarterly reviews matter.

When on-premise still makes sense#

  • The system must keep working if the internet fails. Factory machinery controllers, some point-of-sale setups and building systems.
  • Latency matters. Software that controls equipment or processes huge local files can’t wait for a round trip to a data center.
  • Regulation or a customer contract requires it. Some contracts demand data stay on hardware you control. Read the actual requirement; many can be met in the cloud with the right region and controls.
  • Old software that can’t move. Some line-of-business programs only run on a specific server. You can lift them onto a rented virtual server (IaaS, or infrastructure as a service), but sometimes the cost and risk aren’t worth it until the software is replaced.
  • Steady, predictable, heavy workloads. If a system runs flat out all year, owning the hardware can cost less than renting it.

When cloud usually wins#

  • Standard business software. Email, documents, CRM (customer relationship management), accounting, HR and project tools are mostly sold as SaaS now; see what SaaS means in business.
  • Remote or multi-site teams. Access from anywhere is built in.
  • Growth or seasonal swings. Capacity scales up and down without buying hardware.
  • Small IT teams. Handing hardware and patching to a provider frees scarce people.

A worked example#

A 25-person engineering consultancy runs three things on a server in its office: shared files, an older project-costing program and the door-entry system. Taking them one at a time:

  • Shared files move to a cloud file service. Staff already work from home two days a week, and the server’s operating system is near its end-of-life date.
  • Project costing runs on a rented virtual server for now, managed by the IT partner, until the firm picks a SaaS replacement next year.
  • Door entry stays on a small local device. It must work when the internet doesn’t.

Three systems, three different answers, and the closet server can be retired.

Decision factors#

Go system by system rather than deciding for the whole company at once.

  1. What happens to this system if the internet drops for a day? If the answer is “the business stops,” keep a local option or a solid backup connection.
  2. Is there a good SaaS version? If yes, compare it to the cost of keeping your current setup for five more years.
  3. When is the next hardware or software end-of-life date? That date is the natural time to decide.
  4. Who maintains it today, and how much time does it take? Count your IT partner’s hours honestly.
  5. What data does it hold, and are there rules about where that data lives?
  6. How does it connect to everything else? Systems that need to share data might be easier to integrate in the cloud; our API integration guide explains what to look for.

What this means for a 20-person company

  • Your default should be cloud for standard business software. Keep on-premise only where there’s a clear reason.
  • Make a list of every server you still run, what it does, and its end-of-life date. That list is your migration plan.
  • If you keep anything on-premise, make sure backups go off-site and someone tests restoring them.
  • Count your IT partner’s time in the comparison. Hardware isn’t the only cost of owning servers.

Also consider

  • Hybrid setups: keep one or two local systems and run the rest in the cloud. For many firms that’s a perfectly sensible end state.
  • Colocation: your own hardware in someone else’s data center, with their power, cooling and security.
  • Managed private cloud: dedicated hardware run for you by a provider. Compare the big public options in AWS vs Azure vs Google Cloud.